MORRISTOWN, N.J. — A 31-year-old mother of three could avoid prison time after pleading guilty Tuesday in connection with a Morristown homicide case, but strict conditions will determine her fate.
Guilty Plea and Potential Deal
This Article Includes
Casandrea West, 31, admitted to hindering the apprehension of Robert Everett, 59, by denying knowledge of a June 13 altercation on Patriots Path that led to 65-year-old Stanley Robinson’s death from blunt force trauma.
She also pled guilty to tampering with evidence after removing an empty bag of heroin from Everett’s body. West and co-defendant Enrique “Flaco” Vega, 33, discovered Everett the following day in an abandoned Hanover residence.
Under a proposed deal, West could receive three years of probation. In exchange, prosecutors agreed to drop a third-degree charge of endangering an injured victim.
Courtroom Drama and Emotional Plea
Morris County Assistant Prosecutor Alyssa DiSturco pushed to keep West in custody until her October sentencing, citing her 10-year drug addiction and risk of flight. She requested time for a mandatory drug evaluation.
However, Superior Court Judge Stephen Taylor released West after an emotional plea in which she broke down while reading a letter:
“I beg you to be allowed to go home,” West said, revealing she suffered a seizure, miscarriage, and hospitalization while in custody.
Strict Release Conditions
Judge Taylor set firm conditions for West’s release:
-
Stay with her parents in Sussex County
-
Continue attending a methadone program
-
Undergo a comprehensive drug evaluation
-
Remain substance-free
-
Find and maintain employment
The judge warned, “Rest assured, if there are any stumbles, this is a one-time opportunity.”
Potential Sentencing and Future Challenges
At sentencing, prosecutors will recommend probation without fines, provided West completes treatment as advised. However, her charges carry a maximum penalty of 6.5 years in prison and up to $25,000 in fines if she violates terms.
West’s defense attorney, Tracy Denholtz, argued her release was critical for her children’s well-being, especially one autistic child struggling in her absence. West hopes to work as a waitress and help with a friend’s cleaning business while rebuilding her life.
Meanwhile, co-defendant Enrique Vega was released last week for treatment but still faces multiple charges, including drug offenses, burglary, and theft.
This article has been carefully fact-checked by our editorial team to ensure accuracy and eliminate any misleading information. We are committed to maintaining the highest standards of integrity in our content.
